Ergatta vs Peloton: Is Biking or Rowing the Better Workout?

Ergatta vs Peloton: Is Biking or Rowing the Better Workout? is a reader supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission.

Nowadays, there are a lot more options when it comes to home connected fitness equipment. It seems the demand for smart connected devices has infiltrated the home workout market at a rapid pace. This has led to numerous innovative brands to come up with their very own connected fitness at-home workout equipment.

While this equipment may have lacked affordability and practicality in the past, it has become increasingly accessible and highly convenient.

Because of this, many consumers are flocking to the marketplace to purchase this equipment at a rapid pace. Two of the brands that have come up with innovative products that stand out in the marketplace are Peloton and Ergatta.

‘While they are both connected workout equipment, the experience they offer differ substantially.

If you find yourself having a difficult time choosing between the two, you’ve come to the right place. By the end of this comparison article, you should have a good idea of which connected workout equipment would be right for you.

Features Head-to-Head: Ergatta vs Peloton

1. Ergatta

an overview of the Ergatta rower

  • Elegant Design

The Ergatta is a rowing machine that provides an experience like no other rowing machine you will find in the marketplace. Not only is the machine hand-crafted from American cherry wood in Rhode Island, but the machine oozes elegance. The designers noted they wanted to design a rowing machine that belonged “in the home, not the gym.” [1]. They nailed the design as it truly acts as a centerpiece in any room you put it in. The Verge noted it’s “the prettiest machine you’ll find” [2].

  • Compact, Portable, and Easy to Store

As with any workout equipment that is meant to be in your home, you want it to be complementary rather than excessive. One of the things that hold a lot of people back from investing in-home workout equipment is the significant space requirements the majority of them have.

Ergatta is a rowing machine that is meant to store in the space of a bar stool. Because of this, you don’t have to worry about having a huge machine taking up all of your usable living space. Likewise, the machine features easy and convenient wheels attached at the bottom which makes it easy to wheel the machine around as needed.

The efficient and optimal storage design by Ergatta is a standout in a marketplace full of bulky equipment.

  • Digital HD Touchscreen

With any connected workout equipment nowadays, you want an included digital touchscreen. After all, the premise and appeal of this type of equipment is the ability to have an immersive and gym-like workout experience in the comfort of your own home.

Having a large digital touchscreen can be complimentary or even essential to getting that experience. Luckily, The Ergatta comes with a massive 17.3-inch Android-powered touchscreen.

This screen features a resolution of 1920 x 1080 which offers full-HD viewing. Because of this, the viewing experience offered by this machine during workouts is beyond exceptional.

The level of immersion is certainly there as the action is right in your face and crystal clear.

  • Water Resistance Technology

WaterRower is one of the premier water rowing manufacturers in the world. They have been and continue to create some of the best and most feature-packed water rowing machines.

There is a significant difference between the rowing experience you get from a machine that uses water as a resistance mechanism and one that uses magnets. With a water rower, you pull the handle and there is a flywheel with paddles that spin in the connected tank.

Because the paddles are cutting through the water much as they would in real life, it is capable of offering a much more realistic rowing experience.

Think Ergatta sounds like a good fit?

2. Peloton

an overview of the Peloton bike

  • Best-In-Class HD Touchscreen

With Peloton, you are getting a bike that is designed to offer an experience like no other. Peloton led the charge with its first connected workout experience and they continue to deliver one of the best experiences in the marketplace.

With two bikes to choose from, you can get either a 22-inch HD touchscreen or a 24-inch HD touchscreen. Regardless, you are getting the best display you will find in a connected exercise machine.

With the larger model, you will even get 2-front facing speakers to add to the level of immersion you get from your workouts.

  • Compact

When buying workout equipment, you want to find something that isn’t going to have such a large footprint. Peloton considered this when designing their world-class exercise bike.

With a footprint of only 4’ x 2’, you shouldn’t have any problem fitting the bike into your home. It doesn’t take up much space at all and you can conveniently tuck it next to a wall or in a corner.

  • Full Adjustability

One of the standout features of Peloton bikes over some of the competition is the level of adjustability their bikes offer. The fact is, to get the best possible workout, you need to be able to make manual and fine-tuned adjustments to the bike. That way, you can tweak things just the way you like them.

Not only does it make your workouts much more comfortable, but it can keep you on the bike for longer periods and it can maximize your consistency with your workouts.

The Peloton bike is capable of offering adjustments in multiple areas including the seat, handlebars, and even the screen.

  • Magnetic Resistance

With the Peloton bike, you are getting a bike that uses magnetic resistance. The lower-priced model comes with mechanical adjustment and the more expensive model comes with digital adjustment.

Regardless, each comes with a Poly V power transmission belt drive which means you are getting a near-silent workout experience. No more worrying about having noisy exercise bikes that would wake up your entire house.

With the Peloton, you can get your workouts in whether you are an early riser or a late-night owl.

Workout Comparison: Ergatta’s Gaming-Inspire Experience vs Peloton’s Studio Classes

1. The Ergatta Workout: Gaming Meets Rowing

The Ergatta is much more than meets the eye. At first glance, you may assume it’s a typical rowing machine made to look pretty. While it certainly is pretty, it’s not ordinary rowing machine.

The Ergatta was designed with a unique workout incentive in mind. Rather than simply relying on instructor-led workouts and eternal motivation, it looks to ‘gamify’ the entire workout experience. With the Ergatta, you can pin yourself head-to-head with your personal bests or even with the rest of the Ergatta community.

This can push you to row faster, harder, and longer than ever before. Much like an arcade-like experience would do with public standings, it can push you to deliver your absolute best performance and keep you wanting to workout to achieve higher scores.

Not only does it deliver an incredibly unique ‘gamified’ workout experience, but it also leverages artificial intelligence to provide real-time feedback based on your fitness activity. Meaning, you will be able to get real-time feedback and calibration on your workouts to help you row past plateaus along the way.

See a full list of workout options at the Ergatta website.

2. Peloton: Live and On-Demand Instructor-Led Classes

  • Studio-Like Experience

With Peloton, you are getting a studio/gym-like workout experience. For those who do better in a structured fitness environment, this would be the ideal solution. The Peloton experience is one that immerses its users into a studio training session with other Peloton users. This can make you feel as if you are taking a studio cycling class right in the comfort of your own home.

  • Live or On-Demand – You Choose

These classes can be accessed both live or on-demand. Meaning, you will be able to take the classes at the times most accommodating to your schedule. For many, this makes it much easier to cram in more effective workout sessions because you won’t have constant excuses. Because you won’t ever have to feel as if you are riding alone, it can keep you highly motivated to continue with your workouts.

  • Real-Time Data

The Peloton workout experience provides you with real-time data that you can access which can help you get more out of each workout.

  • Programs and Challenges

You will be able to commit to a fitness-focused goal and earn rewards for completing different challenges along the way.

Rowing vs Biking: Tips for Picking the Right Workout for You

For this, there is no ‘right or wrong.’ It’s mostly subjective. The truth is, the best one is the one you would be willing to commit to. However, there is research that proves rowing is the more effective total body workout. Dr. Cameron Nichol, a doctor and former Olympic rower considers rowing to be the “most time efficient total body workout” available. Because of this, it would be a better option for the majority of people who use ‘not having enough time’ as an excuse to avoid working out.

RELATED READING: How Much Does Ergatta Cost?

Price Comparison

1. Ergatta Pricing Options

The Ergatta starts at $2,199.00. The rowing machine comes without a membership. Therefore, you have to factor in the cost of the membership to get the most out of it.

Membership Cost: $29 per month (or) $290 per year. You will be charged this upon activating your rower.

*Pricing listed here subject to change at any time – See current Ergatta prices.

2. Peloton Pricing Options

Peloton offers two different bikes. The lower-cost bike starts at $1,895.00. The higher priced bike comes in at $2,045 [4]. The bike does not come with a Peloton membership subscription included. Therefore, you will have to add this to the total cost of the bike.

Membership Cost: $39 per month. You will be charged once you activate your Peloton bike.

Winner in Cost?

The Peloton has the cheaper starting point if you opt for their regular bike. However, one could argue the Peloton subscription/membership comes with slightly more value since it’s not limited to bike and cardio workouts. It includes access to strength training and more.

Summary: Picking The Right Workout Option For You

As you can probably tell, you can’t go wrong with either option. The truth is, the Ergatta and the Peloton offer unique workout experiences.
While they are both connected workout equipment, the experience offered by each sits at the top of their respective classes. It comes down to what you want most out of your workout equipment.

My top choice?

Personally, I prefer rowing to biking, or running on a treadmill. It’s a much more complete workout, in my opinion, is more fun than riding a bike, and is a great way build up your arms as well.

That said, here are a few tips for deciding if biking or rowing is the better option for you:

Consider Ergatta If…

  • You value having the more efficient workout equipment.

Rowing offers an inherently more efficient workout experience because it activates more muscle groups and it forces you to work harder throughout your workouts. Therefore, you can expect to get better individual workouts with greater intensity with a rowing machine over a bike.

  • You want to ‘gamify’ your workout experience.

Ergatta hit it out of the park with the ‘gamification’ of their rowing machine. It incentivizes you to keep going and it pushes you beyond your comfort zone to be the best.

  • You want a center-piece.

If you have strayed away from home workout equipment because they stick out like a sore thumb in your living space, Ergatta solves this problem for you. It’s something that will prove to be a conversation starter for years to come.

  • You want a rowing experience.

If you are good with having a rowing experience that offers little else, you will be fully satisfied with the Ergatta membership and workout experience.

  • You want an immersive and fun workout experience.

With its gorgeous screen and with the life-like water resistance technology, it feels like you are rowing on water.

Consider Peloton If…

  • You want to bike.

If you are someone who wants to workout on a bike, the Peloton is the best available.

  • You want a complete workout subscription.

The Peloton membership is comprehensive. It can provide you with various types of workouts which can give you a total body workout. This includes biking, cardio, strength training, and more.

  • You want both live and on-demand workouts.

Peloton offers both live and on-demand workouts ensuring you work out when you want to.

  • You have friends on Peloton.

Because Peloton is so popular, you may already have real-life friends on the platform. This might make it the more attractive buy since it comes with social features.

  • You want a studio-like workout experience.

If you are looking to put yourself in a cycling studio with world-class instructors, Peloton may be right for you. It can help to put you into workout mode and it can keep you pushing towards your fitness goals. If you value structure, Peloton offers a much more structured workout experience.